This section deals mainly with
freezing movement through the use of electronic flash or strobe lighting.
It also examines some associated topics that are important in creating
successful high-speed images, including the use of flash meters, changes
in color balance and the significance of backgrounds.
Terminology
In conventional photography exposure times are usually quoted in
hundredths of a second, as 1/200 sec or 1/500 sec. As one
moves into the realm of high-speed photography, with exposures times
measured in thousandths and millionths of a second, this fractional
notation becomes increasingly cumbersome. It is more convenient to quote
exposures in milliseconds (msec) or microseconds (msec).
Thus an exposure of 1/20,000 second would be given as 50 microseconds.
At TC Nature, for example, we construct our own variable power flash units
with fixed pulse-widths from 1/10,000 to 1/1,000,000 second, or, to use
the easier terminology, from 100 msec to
1 msec.
Strobe Lighting
Strobe lighting was developed by Dr. Harold Edgerton of MIT during the
1930s, but did not become widely available to photographers until after
World War II. The main appeal initially lay in strobe's ability to stop
movement through very short flashes of high-intensity light. In time,
however, the emphasis shifted away from speed and towards power, as studio
photographers revelled in the creative opportunities presented by
unlimited illumination free of the uncertainties of sunlight or cumbersome
floodlights. Today, big studio systems often operate at relatively slow
speeds of around 1/200 sec, whereas most hand-held strobes
typically operate at between 0.5 and 1 msec, many possessing the
ability go down to 50 msec or less.
High-Speed Strobes
So far as we are aware, nobody is currently manufacturing flash
equipment that provides short flash duration together with high power
output. To get short duration flashes one must either commission the
construction of special custom units or rely on small portable strobes.
The former are prohibitively expensive while latter have limited power
output.
Without going into technical details (and strobe theory is very
technical!), strobes specifically designed for high-speed use differ in
several important respects from conventional strobes. Among other things,
they operate at far higher voltages (necessary for short flash duration
but also potentially lethal), they require special hard-to-find
high-energy storage capacitors and they need custom tubes (flashlamps).
Those who feel an irresistible urge to build their own high-speed units
should consider very carefully before embarking on such an undertaking.
Relatively few electrical engineers have experience in the field, which
has many unexpected pitfalls and advice is almost unobtainable.
Information and components are hard to find and there is a constant risk
of lethal shock. One careless mistake can kill - and has killed!
Particularly dangerous are units with separate flash heads connected to a
central power supply. The cables inevitably receive rough usage, get wet
and get trodden on. It is only a matter of time before the insulation
breaks down and massive amounts of stored energy, at several thousand
volts, are explosively discharged with the possibility of serious damage
or injury.
Most people, therefore, are forced to rely on small, mass-produced
thyristor-controlled strobes, which are relatively inexpensive. These can
easily be adapted to produce very short light pulses, but this comes at
the expense of power output because the thyristor cuts of the flash before
the storage capacitor has fully discharged. The shorter the flash, the
less light is produced. It becomes necessary, therefore, to link several
together in order to generate reasonable light levels. Unfortunately, even
this approach soon becomes impractical as the numbers needed rise
exponentially - first 1, then 2, then 4, then 8, 16, and so on, doubling
for each stop gained. Moreover, the effective pulse width begins to
increase due to individual variation between units and difficulty in
ensuring simultaneous firings, so one gradually starts to lose the ability
to stop very fast movement as light levels rise and the flash duration
expands.
Comparing Strobes
You should be aware that most strobe manufacturers are overly
optimistic when quoting performance data for their products. Moreover, the
figures can be misleading. First, not all manufacturers conform to the
same convention when assessing flash duration. Some measure at 1/3 peak,
some at 1/2 and some at 1/10, making comparisons difficult.
It has become customary for the 'power' of a strobe (=
"desirability" in popular imagination) to be represented in
terms of its stored energy, measured in joules or watt-seconds.
Here too the unwary can be seriously mislead, for this measure of stored
energy - the product of voltage and capacitance - can bear scant
relationship to the light energy actually produced by the flashlamp.
Whereas the oil-filled capacitors used in high-speed flash units
typically dissipate over 90 percent of their stored energy, the cheaper
electrolytic capacitors used in conventional strobes may, in extreme
cases, actually retain up to 80 percent of their energy on discharge. It
is, therefore, theoretically possible for two units, rated respectively at
180 watt-seconds and 800 watt-seconds, to put out exactly the same amount
of light, the former converting energy at 40 times the rate of the latter.
Caveat emptor!
Backgrounds
High-speed photographers are plagued by shortage of light and nowhere
is that more apparent than when considering backgrounds. If the background
is the same distance behind the subject as the strobe light is in front,
it will be 2 stops darker (and if twice the distance, 4 stops darker) -
the results of the notorious inverse square law. Lighting the
subject adequately is hard enough - lighting the background is that much
more demanding, which is why many high-speed images have no background
visible. High-speed images showing blue sky must be enhanced in
some way, for in this case the background is infinitely distant and hence
infinitely dark!
It is, of course, essential that the background light has the same
duration as the subject light and be fully synchronized. If conventional
flash is used on the background in conjunction with high-speed flash all
sorts of unacceptable shadows and ghost images are generated. This means
that in most circumstances high-speed images are shot against either pure
black or a substitute photographic print background. There is also the
possibility of adding a background subsequently, either digitally or in
the darkroom.
Flash Metering
People often ask whether it is possible to get accurate readings on a
flash meter if the pulses are very short. We have only tested the later
models of Minolta flashmeters, and find that they are accurate to within
0.2 of a stop at a flash duration of 25 microseconds - an acceptable
value. We have no information on other makes.
Exposure and Color Balance
Just as electrical energy is converted into radiant energy in a
flashlamp, so within a film emulsion light energy is converted into
chemical energy. Over the range of normal exposure times light energy
bears a straight-line relationship to its effects on the emulsion. This is
the basis for the so-called reciprocity law, which allows incremental
changes in exposure time to be matched by reciprocal changes in aperture.
With very short or very long exposure times this relationship breaks down,
necessitating additional exposure time.
Each film emulsion reacts differently, but typically films rated at 64
or 100 ISO will require at least one extra stop at 50 microseconds and 2
extra stops at 25 microseconds to receive proper exposure. This must be
added to any value your flash meter may give.
The spectral composition of light produced in a xenon flashlamp varies
with flash duration, the shorter the pulse the bluer the light because
more ultraviolet is generated. The effect will vary with different makes
of strobe as some incorporate ultraviolet filtration and compensation. We
find that at 25 microseconds a color temperature shift of about +81 mired
is required, meaning that a Wrattan 85c filter will produce an appropriate
correction. This, incidentally will add a further 1/3 stop correction to
the exposure. If color balance is critical - for example involving skin
tones in an advertising shot - it is reassuring to know that the Minolta
Color Temperature meter gives accurate readings with short duration
flashes.
Filmstock
Many photographers are obliged to use relatively fast films because of
having to work at low light levels. If possible, it is best to work with
ISO 64 or ISO 100 film because the fine grain size makes it easier to
produce crisp enlargements. At TC Nature we work with both Kodak and Fuji
fine-grain reversal films.
Because so much trial and error is involved in creating a successful
high-speed image, many photographers make extensive use of Polaroid
instant films. At TC Nature we get through large amounts of Polacolor Pro
100 on every shoot and are profoundly grateful to Polaroid Corporation for
help they have given us in this regard.
Polaroid backs are available for many high-end cameras. These allow
each frame to be processed and viewed immediately, which greatly
simplifies and speeds setting up. The alternative is to use 24 exposure
Polaroid 35mm roll film, which must be developed in a special manual
processor. This is less convenient because, unless you sacrifice many
frames on each roll, you cannot monitor modifications step by step.